A small business website redesign has a failure mode nobody warns you about: the new site launches, looks great — and the enquiries stop, because the URLs changed, the redirects were never set up, and the pages Google had learned to rank quietly disappeared. Rebuilding the traffic can take months.
When I rebuild an existing site, search continuity is part of the launch checklist, not an afterthought. Every existing URL is mapped to its new home, permanent redirects are in place before cutover, page titles and structured data carry across, and Search Console is watched after launch so anything unexpected gets caught in days rather than months. The same discipline applies whether the old site is WordPress, Squarespace, or something older.
If you're not sure what your current site actually ranks for — most owners aren't — the free Basic Digital Health Check shows you before anything is touched, and the SEO foundation underneath is how the new site does better than break even.